A probe into construction failings at the DG One Leisure centre in Dumfries has laid the foot of blame "unquestionably" with the contractor, Kier Construction.
The report, which runs to more than 350 pages, highlighted numerous failings on the development, which opened in 2008 at a cost of £17 million.
However, it was forced to close in October 2014 for major repair works, with vast portions of the centre having to be rebuilt. McLaughlin & Harvey were appointed to carry out the remediation works in 2016.
The author of the report, Professor John Cole CBE, said the inquiry was "surprised" at the range and extent of defects discovered within the building, with issues seeming to permeate "virtually all elements of the building", from the underground drainage through all aspects of the structure and fabric up to the construction of the roof.
He said: "The presence of so many diverse defects is evidence of fundamental failures in the implementation of quality control processes used by the main contractor and the design and build supply chain responsible for delivering the design, construction, supervision and inspection of the building."
Overall, the key findings of the report included;
• the contractors failure to provide the required standard of construction
• fundamental defects in the fire-proofing of the building
• waterproofing the enclosing tanks and drainage connections of pools is a fundamental requirement when constructing a building with three internal swimming pools and a spa pool
• multiple failures on the part of the contractor to adequately comply with the requirements of the Building (Scotland) Act 2003
• inadequate arrangements made for the monitoring of the quality of works on site
• adequately resourcing projects with relevant professional expertise and funding would enable the Council to act as an intelligent and informed customer
Mr Cole, who also led the probe into building failures at 17 of Edinburgh's schools, said the defects at DG One were similar to those that had been identified as the cause of the collapse of a wall at Oxgangs Primary School in January 2016.
He writes: "It is the view of the Inquiry that the widespread presence of these same failures in the DG One building lends further support to the finding of the Edinburgh Schools Inquiry that these failures are indicative of systemic problems in the quality of work provided by the construction industry."
After publishing the report, Dumfries and Galloway Council said Kier did not accept the invitation of the inquiry to send a representative and declined several requests to provide evidence.
Council Leader Elaine Murray said she has now referred the report to Police Scotland.
"We fully acknowledge all the inquiry's findings and thank Professor Cole and his inquiry team," she said.
"The findings of his Inquiry give a damning verdict in the quality of construction of DG One at the hands of Keir Northern.
"Professor Cole's Inquiry contains a number of lessons and issues for the Council to reflect upon. There are also matters for the attention of Scottish and UK Governments. Dumfries and Galloway Council will be acting upon these immediately but legislative changes must also come in response to this Inquiry.
"I have previously referred DG One Leisure Complex to both the Health and Safety Executive and to Police Scotland. Police Scotland have previously indicated that if criminal activity is evident in the report they would be willing to take it further. Based on this, I will now refer the Inquiry Report to Police Scotland."
(LM/MH)
Time and date
CONSTRUCTION DIRECTORY
Construction News
02/05/2018
DG One Probe 'Unquestionably' Blames Contractor For Failings
Latest Construction News
26/11/2024
Scottish Water has unveiled its largest-ever procurement initiative, aiming to modernise the nation's water and wastewater infrastructure while safeguarding the environment. The program, named Delivery Vehicle 4, is valued between £5 billion and £9 billion and is set to run from 2027 to 2033, with ...
26/11/2024
The City of Edinburgh Council has granted planning permission, subject to conditions, for the refurbishment of Calton Square, an office building currently occupied by Baillie Gifford until the end of December 2025. Promoted by Ardstone Capital on behalf of Manova Partners, the project aims to ...
26/11/2024
First Minister John Swinney, MSP for Perthshire North, praised the progress being made on the construction of the new Perth High School during a visit on Friday, 22 November. He was joined by Jim Fairlie, MSP for Perthshire South and Kinross-shire, alongside senior Perth and Kinross Councillors, ...
26/11/2024
A state-of-the-art playpark has officially opened at King George V Park in Bearsden, following the completion of a £100,000 refurbishment. Funded by a combination of East Dunbartonshire Council (EDC) Capital Funding and the Scottish Government’s Renewing Scotland’s Play Parks initiative, the ...
26/11/2024
Fife Council has launched a public consultation, inviting residents, businesses, and organizations to contribute ideas and propose sites for inclusion in the next Local Development Plan, known as Fife's Place Plan. The council is calling on community councils, landowners, and developers to share ...
26/11/2024
The Chief Executive of East Lothian Council has announced she is to retire in February 2025. Monica Patterson who has been Chief Executive for almost five years, has spent most of her professional career working in local government. Prior to joining East Lothian Council in 2010, she was Head of ...
25/11/2024
West of Scotland Housing Association (WSHA) and Connect Modular have jointly submitted a planning application to Glasgow City Council for the development of 33 affordable homes in Cowlairs. This project aligns with the wider Cowlairs Park regeneration scheme and the city's ambitious housing ...
25/11/2024
Arc-Tech (Scotland) has successfully completed a £6m Mechanical and Electrical (M&E) services package for the Lost Shore Surf Resort in Edinburgh. The state-of-the-art resort, which opened its doors earlier this month, features a range of amenities, including a wave pool, luxury lodges, and ...
25/11/2024
Scottish Water has successfully completed the construction of a groundbreaking hydro energy generation scheme at Whiteadder Reservoir in East Lothian. This innovative project, believed to be the first of its kind in Europe, will harness the power of water to offset a significant portion of the ...
25/11/2024
Work is set to commence on a £6.5 million project to upgrade the Double Dykes Gypsy/Traveller site near Perth. The initiative aims to replace outdated chalets with modern, energy-efficient accommodation and implement significant site improvements. Perth & Kinross Council secured £3.9 million from ...